Your Guide to Natural Health
About Us  |  Contact Us  |  Subscribe  |  Advertise


Vitamin D News: New Meta-Analysis Reveals the Truth About Prescription D2 vs. Over-the-Counter D3

Posted by
     

Vitamin D

Many people write me and ask, “My doctor prescribed Drisdol, is that OK?” Drisdol is D2 and the form of that doctors write prescriptions for. The body doesn’t produce 2 in response to sun exposure. It is made by irradiating fungus and plant matter. When you take it, a number of metabolic forms of D2 are found in the body, and some studies show D3 (produced by the skin) is more potent, meaning it is more effective at raising blood levels than D2, while some show they are equal. However, there are few studies comparing the efficacy of D2 vs. D3. Or in other words, which form has better health outcomes, better mortality rates?

Recently, a review and meta-analysis address this question. The meta-analysis study was led by Professor Dr. Goran Bjelakovic.

Bjelakovic G, Gluud LL, Nikolova D, Whitfield K, Wetterslev J, Simonetti RG, Bjelakovic M, Gluud C. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2011 Jul 6;(7):CD007470.

He analyzed 50 randomized controlled trials (RCTs) with a total of 94,000 participants that used some form of vitamin D and reported mortality rates as either primary or secondary outcomes. Within these RCTs, 32 of the studies used D3 (74,000 subjects) and 12 of them used D2 (18,000 subjects). He found there was a 6% relative risk reduction when supplementing with vitamin D3, as opposed to a 2% relative risk increase when supplementing with vitamin D2.

Amazingly, this study somehow slipped under the radar and neither the press nor I picked up this study in July. Luckily, Professor Dr. Harvey Murff of Vanderbilt University reviewed this study yesterday in the Annals of Internal Medicine recently, allowing the general public to examine the study once again.

Murff HJ. Review: Cholecalciferol (vitamin D3) reduces mortality in adults; other forms of vitamin D do not. Ann Intern Med. 2011; 155:JC5-04.

You would think a paper that took a look at tens of thousands of subjects and analyzed the efficacy of prescription vitamin D (D2) and over-the-counter vitamin D (D3) would warrant a news story or two. To my knowledge, these papers are the first to paint such a clear picture about the efficacy between D3 and D2. While there may be explanations for D3’s superiority other than improved efficacy, for the time being, these papers send doctors a message: use D3, not D2.

Contacts:

Vitamin D Council: newsletter@vitamindcouncil.org

Professor Harvey Murff, Vanderbilt University: harvey.j.murff@vanderbilt.edu

Professor Dr Goran Bjelakovic G, University of Nis, Serbia: g.bjelakovic@ctu.rh.dk or goranb@junis.ni.ac.yu


Republished with permission from the Vitamin D Council.


Join Our Email List

Share the knowledge!
   
Article updated on: November 16th, 2011

Tags: , ,


Leave a Comment Below


Share Your Thoughts

17 Responses to “ Vitamin D News: New Meta-Analysis Reveals the Truth About Prescription D2 vs. Over-the-Counter D3 ”

  1. Vitamin D2 or D3? | LeanMachine Health Blog on November 30, 2011 at 4:46 AM

    [...] an article posted on Live in the Now, Dr. John J. Cannell writes: “Amazingly, this study somehow slipped under the [...]

  2. [...] those who used vitamin D3, butA two percent relative risk increase among those who used D2In an article posted on Live in the Now, Dr. John J. Cannell writes:“Amazingly, this study somehow slipped under the radar…You [...]

  3. [...] an article posted on Live in the Now, Dr. John J. Cannell writes: “Amazingly, this study somehow slipped under the [...]

  4. [...] an article posted on Live in the Now, Dr. John J. Cannell writes: "Amazingly, this study somehow slipped under the [...]

  5. [...] an article posted on Live in the Now, Dr. John J. Cannell [...]

  6. [...] he or she will probably write you a prescription for the synthetic D2 version, which has been shown to be poorly absorbed and less effective than the natural form.[8] Just because your doctor prescribes it doesn’t mean it’s more [...]

  7. [...] D3. La vitamina D2, che è la forma comunemente prescritta dai medici, è ricavata dalle piante e aumenta il tasso di mortalità del 2%. La forma D3 è quella comunemente prodotta nel corpo umano tramite l’esposizione al [...]

  8. [...] Live in the Now November 16, 2011 [...]

  9. The Two Types of Vitamin D | OrganicREADY on October 8, 2012 at 1:31 PM

    [...] As stated by Dr. Cannell in the featured article: [...]

  10. [...] sure you choose a vitamin D product that contains D3 in the form of cholecalciferol — the form best absorbed and utilized by the [...]

  11. Vitamin D2 vs D3: Which One Do I Want? on January 13, 2013 at 3:27 AM

    [...] an article posted on Live in the Now, Dr. John J. Cannell writes: “Amazingly, this study somehow slipped under the [...]

  12. [...] or by taking a supplement.Make sure you choose a vitamin D product that contains D3 in the form of cholecalciferol — the form best absorbed and utilized by the body.If you are concerned that you are deficient in [...]

  13. Michael Kors Bags on March 24, 2013 at 3:27 AM

    When i bring in my own Michael Kors Bags http://michael-kors-bags-118.webs.com Continuously! What individuals has feelings for you the appear like, aided by the winters you’ll find for New york city, fashionth is most significant. When i bring in my using footwear plus my own ft . continue being nice and manner, even during a excellent skiing conditions! They will do a smaller sizeable as a result buy the whole over all size along. You possibly can saunter all day long within them. They are really particularly excellent. Worth it almost every pair which i private!

  14. [...] sure you choose a vitamin D product that contains D3 in the form of cholecalciferol — the form best absorbed and utilized by the [...]

  15. The Great Vitamin-D Scam | Wake Up World on July 22, 2013 at 6:42 PM

    [...] he or she will probably write you a prescription for the synthetic D2 version, which has been shown to be poorly absorbed and less effective than the natural form.[8] Just because your doctor prescribes it doesn’t mean it’s more [...]

  16. vitamins for bones orthomol on November 26, 2013 at 3:38 AM

    What is vitamin a

  17. blackheads rosacea treatment emedicine on August 30, 2014 at 9:55 AM

    The best coolant for the skin is cucumber,
    because it has the ability to absorb heat within the skin which is
    a precursor of acne. You can rub a little portion of garlic on your
    acne, more than once in a day. If you would like to learn more about the facial care line at
    Kiss My Face, visit their main web site at:.